The Other Scale Debate of Marxism: “Socialism in One Country” or World Revolution?

Sungur Savran

This article undertakes to clarify the question regarding the scale of the overthrowing of
capitalism and the construction of a classless society, by now an almost classical scale debate
within Marxism, one that predates the current host of questions that relate to scale. The author
deliberately avoids including Trotsky and the Stalin-Trotsky debate in the argument, but rather
concentrates on the ideas of Marx and Engels and of Lenin and the Bolsheviks and compares
and contrasts these with those of the major faction of the Bolshevik Party under Stalin. It is
argued that both in the case of Marx and Engels and in that of the Bolsheviks, the whole edifice
of the theory rises on the basis of the central idea of a world revolution. The author cites clear
evidence that both the programmatic documents and the theoretical work of all Marxists up until
1928, when “socialism in one country” became the centerpiece of the Comintern programme,
were explicit on the necessity of world revolution and the rejection of any ideas implying the final
construction of a classless society within the borders of a single country. The article further
examines the foundations of the theory and programme of “socialism in one country” and finds
them extremely fragile, if not outright unsustainable. The final verdict of the article is that the
collapse of the Soviet Union and the countries of Eastern and Central Europe confirms the truth
of Marxism rather than refutes it.