Intellectuals and Classes: Three Theoretical Models

Mehmet Yetiş

This paper focuses on three theoretical models concerning the relationship
between intellectuals and social classes. The first model is represented by Alvin
W. Gouldner, George Konrád, and Ivan Szelényi, who contend that intellectuals
form a distinct social class. I argue that this “new class” approach, which is
based on the concept of “cultural capital”, can be classified within the neo-
Weberian paradigm. The second model is represented by Karl Mannheim, who
sees intellectuals as a classless aggregation or an interstitial stratum located
between the two great classes of labor and capital. I emphasize that his “freefloating
intelligentsia” is an ultra-epistemological subject, capable of making a
grandiose synthesis of the conflicting ideological standpoints such as
conservatism, fascism, communism, etc. The third model can be derived from the
prison writings of Antonio Gramsci, whose analysis on the organic and traditional
intellectuals provides a possibility for a dialectical approach to the complexity of
social relations. Here, I argue that he treats the concept of intellectual in a novel
way, and that he tries to uncover the hegemonic position of the dominant class
with an in-depth inquiry into the relations between intellectual groups and the
principal social classes in a capitalist milieu.